Chp 2 |
Compare and contrast the early colonial empires of Portugal,
Spain, and England in terms of motives, economic foundations, and relations
with African and Indians. What factors affected these similarities and
differences? |
Clemmer |
|
|
The early colonial empires of Portugal, Spain, and England varied from one
another through their motives, both economically and spiritually. These
varying motivating factors led each colony to possess different relations
with the Africans and the Indians. However their different intricacies of
the relationships between all the colonies and the Indians and Africans,
each shared the view of a superior culture to the Africans and Indians. The
Africans were viewed by all empires as a source of labor. Also, despite the
initial intentions of neutrality between the Indians and some early
colonizing empires, eventually, if not initially, all colonies came to
believe that the Indians posed a problem for attempt at expansion.
The Portuguese were the first to prove long range voyages were feasible.
Motivated to purify (Christianize) the heathens, the Treaty of Tordesillas
in 1494 divided the New World between Portugal and Spain. Though they
received land, namely Brazil, this treaty paved the way for the Spanish
Conquistadores to embark upon the New World. The Portuguese ignited the
unrecoverable cultural hiatus in the Africa’s long before the Europeans had
any notion of the slave trade. Portuguese set up the trading posts along
the African shore with goods of gold and slaves opening up this trade to the
English and Spanish for future use and a great factor to their colonizing
empires.
Spain and Portugal were feuding rivals. Spain was quickly taking shape
shortly after its unification and embarked on the race to beat Portugal to
wealth found in the New World as well as in the Indies. The Spanish were
also motivated to purify the heathens, but unlike the Portuguese, they also
quested for glory and gold. These economic motives combined with well
trained military officers and technology made the Conquistadores an
unstoppable force. Led by men like Cortez and Pizarro, the native Incans and
Aztecs were no match for the Spanish. The Spanish did not desire a
relationship with the native Indians, but viewed them as a roadblock that
required extinguishing. Spain would control much of the New World as they
trekked and conquered all the way to the Pacific Ocean.
The advance of the English posed a threat to the new Spanish empire.
Unemployment as well as the thirst for adventure, markets, and religious
freedom caused pilgrimage to the New World. The English sought out to
secure their economic foundation through colonization. Creating trade
companies and utilizing the native’s resources allowed the English to
establish better relations with the Indians than the Spanish, an advantage
that proved favorable in the long run. The Indian’s offered food to the
struggling Jamestown colonists and staged the kidnapping and rescuing of an
English captain to show the want of peace. However, the Indian’s became
quickly disposable and were no longer any use to the colonists as they fell
victim to disease and disorganization. The Indian’s were pushed out of
their native lands and plantations began to grow. As the New World’s
economy began to stabilize and flourish, slaves became in high demand as a
source of cheap labor. |
Fodor |
|
|
Portugal, Spain, and England each had their
own colonial empires located throughout the New World. Portugal occupied
the eastern coast of present day South America along with parts of Africa
and China. Spain had colonies throughout Spanish South American and
through the southern parts of North America. The English colonies were
mainly located on the east coast of North America. Although these three
countries colonized throughout the same continents, they each had there
own motives, economic foundations, and relations with the Africans and
Indians.
In 1450,
Portugal created a new ship that was able to travel to the southern parts
of Africa, which were previously unattainable by means of the sea to
Europeans. Once they accomplished this feat, they were able to set up
trading posts in Africa, primarily trading gold and slaves. Also in
Africa, plantations were created on some of the islands, where African
slaves did the labor. Portugal was also able to find a quicker route to
India, or the Indies, because of there superior ships. This gave the
Portuguese a great amount of wealth, which was allowed them to colonize in
the Americas.
Spain soon
realized that they too needed a fast route to the Indies in order to
attain some of the wealth of that land. This desire along with the recent
unification of Spain, were the motives of the Spanish to look towards the
west. Once in the Americas, Spain was on the search for gold. In 1494
Spain and Portugal signed the Treaty of Tordesillas, splitting a part of
the Americas between the two. Here Spanish conquistadors explored
throughout South America and up through Mexico. Many of the Indians
living throughout the Americas had vast quantitities of gold and other
valuable items. The Spanish, hungry for wealth and power, used hostility
to take these treasures from the Indians. Throughout the Spanish
colonization, they treated the Indians poorly. However the Indians did
adapt characteristics of the Spanish cultures to their own cultures.
The English,
similar to the Spanish, longed for a passage to the Indies. However they
did not have the same wealth as the Spaniards had. The Spanish Armada's
defeat allowed the English to no longer be hindered by the Spanish
fleets. England then had religious unity, a sense of nationalism, and a
strong national state with a popular monarch. Like Spain, England went to
the Americas seeking gold and a route to get to the Indies. Once in the
Americas, the English had a tense relationship with the Indians, but they
did have a relationship. Unlike the Spanish, the English did not attack
all of the Indians villages that they came upon. After a longer amount of
time, the Americas became the farming lands for the products of the
English. Huge plantations were built, similar to those built by the
Portuguese in Africa. Also like Portugal, America depended on slaves to
work these plantations.
Spain and
Portugal were probably the most different in their colonization patterns
since they both began at the same time. Also Portugal was more focused in
Africa, while Spain was more in America. The English had characteristics
of the two colonial empires because their efforts came later and probably
knew about the attempts of the others.
|
Ortiz |
|
|
Although
Spain,
England
and
Portugal
may have had similar motives for creating colonies in the
Americas,
their economic foundations and relations with Africans and Indians were
completely different. Each sought gold and more: the Spanish wanted riches
and adventure, the English sought gold and an independent religious society,
and the Portuguese wanted assets and to become an empire.
The Spanish were funded by
their government and made quite a profit for King Ferdinand and Queen
Isabella. The recently united
Spain
became a large, rich economic power due to their empire-building success.
Some of the success may have come from their relations with the natives.
Although they were cruel at times, they married Indians. Spanish men were
obligated to marry Native American women because Spanish women were few and
far between. Not many women came because they weren’t going to settle in the
New World
like many English expected to do. In fusing with the indigenous people
through marriage, the Spanish also integrated some of the native culture
into their own. Many Spaniards were seeking an adventure like that of
Odysseus’ in addition to vast amounts of precious metals.
The English were sent by the
Virginia Company of
London
to settle an area with their families and find gold. The fact that they
brought their family effected their relations with Indians. If they hadn’t
had women to marry, they would have integrated with the indigenous culture
like the Spanish did, but they didn’t and ended up shunning the Indians.
This eventually led to isolation and created a large gap between the English
and Indians that became impossible to bridge.
The Portuguese were funded by
their government, like the Spanish, and set up most of their colonies in
present day
Brazil,
a present day Portuguese speaking nation. They were pioneers in the slave
and plantation system.
Portugal
had set up trading posts along eastern
Africa
and their sugar plantations were very profitable. They wanted to extend
their slave trading and sugar plantation system to the
Americas
to make more money and become an empire.
The relations between different
European nations and Indians and Africans, varied very greatly between
Spain,
Portugal
and
Britain,
but still basically remained the same. Europeans had direct or indirect
control over the world until very recently and were the world’s scholars and
doctors. They had a strong hold of control over the Indians and Africans
because of their educational and technological advancements. These always
gave them the upper hand in dealing with world affairs and keeping
themselves at the top of the food chain.
|
Ponder |
|
|
|
Proto |
|
|
The empires of
Portugal,
Spain
and
England
were all wealthy colonies with expansive colonial regions. Much of the
New World
was owned by
England,
yet nearly half was owned by Imperial Spain.
Portugal
owned significantly less land than
England
and
Spain.
The Spanish made their new world debut in
Santa Fe,
during the year 1610. The English inhabited the new world in 1607 at
Jamestown,
Virginia.
The colonial empire of
England
was one of the most expansive and successful of all the colonial regions
owned by the aforementioned countries.
England
had managed to kill nearly 90 percent of the Indians living in the regions
in which they wished to inhabit. This genocide of the Indians was brought
on mainly by disease, (smallpox especially.) They also brought many
different fruits and vegetables to add to the Indians broad agricultural
system. Cattle, swine and horses were also brought to the new world from
England.
The horse totally revolutionized the Indian tribes living in the new world.
They adopted the creature and benefited greatly from the English settlers.
The relationship between the Indians and the English was an interesting
one. At first, the English were willing to bargain and negotiate with the
native people of the land in which they wished to share. Before too long,
sharing was not an option, and the English began to wrest the land from the
Indians without an ounce of mercy. The English were an extremely strong
people. They were determined to make the new world theirs, and that they
did. The primary colonial empire of the 17th century in
North America
was
England.
Their people were mainly protestant and a majority of the settlers followed
the puritanical extremes of Christianity,
The Spanish empire inhabited
nearly half of the new world during their time. Buccaneers, who were
encouraged by Queen Elizabeth, swarmed shipping lanes to try to promote
Protestantism and invaded Spanish ships and settlements. Sir Francis Drake
was the most popular among these tirades. The English were persistent, and
invaded Spanish territory, eventually leading to the downfall of
Spain.
The problem worsened for
Spain
when the Spanish Netherlands declared that they wished to be independent.
Meanwhile,
England
was a very united colonial empire. Religion, economic and leadership issues
were few and far between. This launched
England
into a new age, a peace treaty was signed with
Spain
in 1604. This readied
England
for a truly remarkable colonization of the new world. The Spanish were
considerably less hostile with the Native Americans than the English were.
Portugal
owned very little land in the new world during the 1600’s. The Portuguese
empire was a speck of dust in comparison to
Spain
and especially the English empires. The substantiality of the Portuguese
domain wasn’t large, it did not make any staggering changes that we benefit
from today, unlike the English. Without the English colonies, it is hard to
say what
north America
would be comprised of today. If the Spanish didn’t decline,
America
could be a Latin American country. This is the reason why the English made
the most profound impact of the new world. |
Schepman |
|
|
The Endless Empires
The old saying, “The sun never
sets on the
British Empire” is derived from the imperialistic
time period. It refers to the rapid physical and economic growth in
Britain during the age of
exploration and colonialism, and the tremendous influence it, (and other
countries like it,) proceeded to have on the rest of the world. Imperialism
among nations became very popular beginning in the thirteenth and fourteenth
centuries. It was a means for a country to become wealthier and larger.
During this time period,
Portugal,
England, and
Spain became imperialistically
involved. These countries all desired to seek out nations that were rich in
natural resources and versatile raw materials. Although these countries
yearned to expand their empires, and make money; their motives, economic
interests, and relations with the foreigners were somewhat analogous,
however, were also dissimilar.
The Portuguese, English, and Spanish were united
in their belief that they were the dominant countries, and thus “deserved”
to conquer advantageous countries for self-benefit. These countries sought
after money and glory to please their King and/or Queen. They conquered
lands in the name of “God, Glory and Gold.” They demanded an increase
in land and money.
These countries sought after
different materials which kept them rich. The English were interested in
America’s cotton in the south
and tobacco in the north. The enslaved Africans cultivated and planted
these crops, which enabled the English to be financially supported. The
Portuguese set up trading posts in
Africa in search of slaves and gold. The gold
provided them with money; however, the slave trade was an invaluable
monopoly. These slaves were traded and highly priced throughout much of the
world at this time. The slave trade allowed
Portugal to become an important
part of Portuguese imperialism. The Spanish were in search of the immense
amount of gold in South America. After the conquistadores conquered
a country, Spanish Missionaries were built to expand the Catholic Church to
the local “pagans”.
The Portuguese and English, in particular,
oppressed certain groups of people in order to keep their already
established colonies in tact. They resorted to the African slave trade to
keep their colonies rich. The slaves were forced to work under poor working
conditions, and were not paid. The Spanish and English, however, caused
mass-death among the Indians. When the Spanish and English came to their
respective colonies, (South America and
America,) they brought with them
diseases such as small pox. This, along with the bison hunting, (the
Indians’ main food source,) caused the Indians to die out, and basically
become an endangered people. Approximately ninety percent of Indians died
due to disease and starvation.
The Portuguese, English, and Spanish empires
sought to expand their empires. The subsequent mixing of cultures and
colonial expansion forever changed history. Imperialism led to the increase
of travel around the world. It also furthered the already prevalent
European dominance, as well as the further developing of the British,
Portuguese, and Spanish Empires. |